Why did not you reload the server ? The respawn time was at 12 ! Not very fair play :/

Disappointed, do you know what fair play means? Not reloading while there's a bug respawn at the beginning of a half, nice guys...

"5.E Broken Timers and Countdown Captures
IF a referee is not present: If a timeout is used during the first half of the map, the map must be reloaded before the second half starts. If a capture is made during countdown and stays displayed in the scoreboard only a referee may restart the map after notifying both teams. If no referee is present, the match continues and the staff are notified there is an extra capture in the score for one of the teams. We strongly discourage capturing during countdown."

You requested a reload when we where playing the second half already for several minutes, the score was 3 -1 in our favor (don't recall the exact score, but we had more). We didn't make any caps during the countdown. So if I read the rules correctly, only a referee should restart the map, which was not present.

So to my opinion we still played fair, sorry to hear you guys think otherwise.
I had fun, and I think it was a good game.

"only a referee should restart" We didn't find any referee... so?

Admins shall decide, I don't want to complicate things with this childishness
Gg guys

What happened was we were winning 2-0 if i recall and only then u asked for reload.
In warmup the respawn timer was wrong, u never complained, while game was playing respawn timer was wrong and u never complained, but as soon as we cap twice u complain and reload server ?
I think its funny.

This comment has been deleted by the Poster

I dont get why admin force to replay the second half.
If they agree they should replay it... but force? common... its was the same situation for both sides, for all players so there was no advantage for fid.
They "rup rup rup" before second half start so i guess both teams forgot to do it or to say to do it.... and asked for reload after 2-0 (2 mins past) - oasis also could call timeout and look for admin or reff - so not that u didnt find him, u didnt even look

According to rules, you have to reload the map if there is a spawn bug. As both teams didn't notice before starting the game, the side with the bugged spawns has to be replayed!

i dont see the replay part in the rules... u are just interpretating rules in one clans favour...
both teams had the same conditions in that half as it was played

If a timeout is used during the first half of the map, the map must be reloaded before the second half starts.
This decision of a replay is not in favour of ANY team, it is a fair decision. You don't need to replay the match, just one side of one map where the timers were bugged. Nothing more.

you requested to reload the server on second half. So we didn't broke any rule.

Anyway, conditions were the same for both teams.

The question now is...where is the last screenshot goyave?

I thik you have a child behavior.

All screenshots have to stay uploaded, even the screenshot of the half that was not counted!

i wait second half
so when can you play?

I won't play with those stupid and crying children.

We played a fair match. Respawn was wrong on the second half so we didn't broke any rule.

Contitions were the same for both teams.

ButterdBread, the decision of a replay of the second half of the second map in only in favour of Oasis, because that was the side where FiD won. We have totally NOTHING to gain by only replaying that half, and Oasis has everything to gain.

So to my opinion this decision is not fair for FiD.

I've understood that you aligned with the other referees and that the decision is not debatable anymore. That's too bad.

My proposal is to at least update the rules of the CFT section such that it is clear that playing with broken timers should ALWAYS be replayed, because the rules now are definitely unclear.

For replaying the second half.... right now a few members are very frustrated with the decision and they don't want to replay the second half. We will come back with a statement what we are going to do....

Regards

You may have a point when saying the rules are sometimes not clear and we're always happy when we get some advice on how to make them better and more understandable.

I will have a closer look at this again, as I want to take every complaint seriously, but until I report something different the decision for a replay stays valid.

This is risible.
The match is played - no rules are broken.
Same conditions for both sides.

Maybe i am still to old for such a kindergarten...

I think if you would have made a draw while the game was "almost" won in your favor, you would all scream with dissatisfaction.
So to say that is the children or we cry for nothing, do in the experiment..